1. The Best (and Worst) Times to Ask
Timing a raise conversation is as important as what you say. The same request lands completely differently depending on when you make it — and many well-deserved raises get denied simply because the timing was off.
2. How to Prepare Your Case
The single biggest mistake people make is walking into a raise conversation with feelings instead of facts. Your manager may want to give you a raise — but they often need to justify it to their own manager and to HR. Give them the ammunition to do so.
Build Your “Value Dossier”
Before the conversation, compile a concise one-page document covering:
- Quantified accomplishments — revenue generated, costs reduced, time saved, customers retained. Use specific numbers wherever possible.
- Scope expansion — any responsibilities you’ve taken on beyond your original job description
- Market data — Glassdoor, LinkedIn Salary, and BLS data showing comparable roles paying more
- Tenure and reliability — how long you’ve been in the role, your performance review history
- Your ask — a specific number, not a range
Start keeping a running “brag doc” — a private document where you log wins, positive feedback, and metrics on an ongoing basis. When raise season comes, you’ll have six months of evidence ready instead of scrambling to remember what you did.
“Your manager doesn’t remember your wins as well as you do. Your job is to make forgetting impossible.”
3. What Number to Ask For
Being specific is critical. “I’d like a raise” is weak. “I’d like to discuss bringing my salary to $X” is a real ask that can be acted on.
| Situation | How Much to Ask For | Strategy |
|---|---|---|
| Annual review, strong performance | 8–12% | Lead with accomplishments, cite market data |
| Significantly underpaid vs. market | 15–25% | Data-heavy approach; may need multiple conversations |
| Took on more responsibilities | 10–18% | Frame as title/compensation alignment, not just a raise |
| Have a competing offer | Match or exceed the offer | Present it professionally; give them a chance to respond |
| Cost-of-living adjustment only | 4–6% | Frame as maintaining real compensation in an inflationary environment |
Never give a range when asked what you want. If you say “$85K–$95K,” they’ll hear $85K. Give one number — the top of what you want — and let the negotiation come down from there.
4. Word-for-Word Scripts
Use these as starting points — customize with your specific accomplishments and data. The language that works is always confident, specific, and grounded in value — not personal need.
Script A: The Email Request (to set up the conversation)
Script B: The In-Person Conversation Opener
Script C: Leveraging a Competing Offer (Professionally)
5. Handling Every Possible Response
“I’ll need to check with HR / my manager.”
Good sign — they didn’t say no. Respond: “Of course — take the time you need. When should I follow up?” Then follow up exactly when they said, and no sooner.
“We can do X%” (lower than you asked for)
Don’t accept immediately. Pause and say: “I appreciate the offer. That’s closer, but still short of the $[TARGET] I was hoping for. Is there any room to bridge that gap with a signing bonus or a 6-month check-in?”
“You’re already at the top of your salary band.”
This is a structural problem, not a personal one. Respond: “I understand. In that case, I’d like to discuss a title adjustment that opens a higher band. What would that path look like?”
“Now isn’t a great time financially.”
Acknowledge it, then pin down a future date: “I understand. When do you think the timing would be better? Can we set a specific date to revisit this?” Get it in writing if possible.
6. What to Do if They Say No
A no today doesn’t have to be a no forever — but you need to respond strategically, not emotionally.
- Ask specifically: “What would I need to accomplish in the next 6 months to earn a raise?” Get the criteria in writing.
- Set a follow-up date: “Can we schedule a check-in for [date] to review progress?”
- Assess what the no tells you: Is this a temporary cash flow issue, or a ceiling on how the company values your role?
- If no path is offered: update your LinkedIn, talk to recruiters, and start gathering market data. A genuine competing offer is the most effective follow-up to a no.
A professional “no” is data, not rejection. It tells you either what you need to achieve, or that your growth ceiling at this company is lower than your market value. Both are useful things to know.
Not Sure If You’re Being Paid Fairly?
Paste your current salary and role details into our free AI tool — it will benchmark you against real market data and generate a personalized raise conversation strategy.
⚡ Check My Market Value →7. Mistakes That Kill Raise Requests
| Mistake | Why It Backfires | Do This Instead |
|---|---|---|
| Using personal needs as justification | “I need more money for rent” — employers don’t pay for your expenses, they pay for your value | Always anchor on market data and accomplishments |
| Threatening to quit without an offer | Empty threats destroy trust and may trigger a managed exit | Only mention another offer if you actually have one |
| Asking via Slack or text | Too casual — signals the conversation isn’t serious | Always have a real-time conversation (video or in-person) |
| Accepting the first no without a follow-up plan | Leaves the conversation unresolved with no accountability | Always secure a specific follow-up date or criteria |
| Comparing yourself to a specific colleague | Creates internal conflict and looks petty | Reference market data, not what “Sarah makes” |